The Professor in the Cage Lesson
Your essay should be 1,100 words and have a Works Cited page canada goose jacket outlet store with 3 sources, including one from the El Camino College database.
canada goose Option 2One. Like animals, men are hard wired for violence in order to achieve safety, reproductive rights, and honor. The hard wiring is so deep that we can see young males, both human and in the animal kingdom, show an instinct for play fighting. As males grow older, they are inclined to organized contests, duels, and competitions that test their might, agility, and courage. canada goose
canada goose coats canada goose outlet winnipeg address Two. Men canada goose vest outlet use ritualized violence to canada goose outlet winnipeg preserve their honor code, https://www.getcanadagooseoutlet.com a display of courage, which earns respect. Ritualized violence builds heart and courage, which are essential to gaining respect from others and oneself. canada goose coats
cheap Canada Goose Three. Men find that jousts and organized forms of combat provide authenticity and real feeling in a world taken over by artificial lifestyles and BS. Fighting sheds the BS and the artificial. cheap Canada Goose
canada goose canada goose outlet online reviews store Four. Ritualized violence, which occurs have tempers have flared, contains rules and allows men to exorcise their aggression in a venue that is far safer than a street fight or a fight of passion. canada goose store
canada goose coats on sale Some Arguments to Refute Gottshall’s Claim That Ritualized Violence canada goose shop uk Is Beneficial canada goose coats on sale
One. We no longer need ritualized violence to establish male hierarchies canada goose outlet of male power and dominance because we have Hobbes’ Leviathan, canada goose outlet belgium a social contract and jurisprudence to litigate what is rightfully ours in terms of property and civil behavior.
Canada Goose Outlet Two. canada goose outlet ontario Gottschall’s points lose credibility in the context of his own admission to write a “gimmick memoir,” a sign of publishing ambition, not a quest for truth. Could his desire to write such a book be a mix of ambition and authenticity? Canada Goose Outlet
Canada canada goose outlet legit Goose online Three. Gottschall’s reliance on male hard wiring argument is fatalistic or deterministic canada goose outlet sale and dismisses conditioning and free choice for civil behavior. Take for instance Steve Almond’s diatribes against canada goose outlet online the NFL, which could be used as a source for your essay. Almond concedes that males love violence, but that they can make canada goose outlet uk a choice to move forward, progress, and leave their troglodyte ways behind because of an ideological shift in their thinking and actions. In contrast, Gottschall is almost celebrating the ideology canada goose outlet factory of ritualized male violence. He ignores the moral bankruptcy of making barbarism of a spectacle of entertainment, as Steve Almond argues. Instead, Gottschall asserts that barbaric spectacle is natural and therefore morally justified. Canada Goose online
buy canada canada goose outlet michigan goose jacket canada goose outlet las vegas cheap Four. While prison population and poor class share the need for respect with the aristocracy in what Gottschall calls “dueling culture,” the comparison is somewhat faulty. The Law of the Jungle does apply in conditions where there is no Leviathan, the social contract canada goose outlet online store of order, but the aristocracy created their code in order canada goose kensington parka uk to preserve their brand in order to maximize their efficacy in the world of business and commerce. That’s a significant difference. buy canada goose jacket cheap
Five. By Gottschall’s own admission, he is a broken man who suffered deep psychic wounds of masculine humiliation when he was bullied and by Gottschall’s own firsthand experience, MMA devotees mostly suffered similar humiliation. Taking these personal grievances does not make for a universal principle about men needing ritualized violence. True, many men, especially young men, are fascinated with MMA and UFC fighting and their market niche is coveted by advertisers. But this marketing gold age bracket does not make for an argument for the universality of the male need for barbaric spectacle as a form of canada goose outlet hong kong healthy entertainment. To the contrary, many men outgrow their fascination for violence and evolve into higher states of development. They sometimes spit on each other, as Richard Ford did at a party when he spotted a book critic who lambasted Ford’s book. Petty canada goose outlet trillium parka black jealousies and rivalries exist even in the “intellectual world.”
buy canada goose jacket Six. Gottschall tries to make a universal point about the male hunger for ritualized violence, but his argument suffers because Gottschall doesn’t address the role of social class. Some would argue that the uneducated class of men will be fixated on ritualized violence throughout their lifetime becoming “fanboys” for their team, showing up to NFL games in the sixties wearing no shirt with their team’s logo painted on the gray hairs of their bare chest. buy canada goose jacket
In contrast, the educated class may be drawn to violent sport for a while, but eventually outgrow this fixation as they set their sights on higher aspirations.
A counterargument to the above is that lots of educated men maintain a passion for violent sports throughout their lifetime. What is Gottschall’s claim about bullying?
canada goose black friday sale He claims that bullying is not abnormal, pathological behavior. canada goose black friday sale
canada goose deals He was bullied and he would have been a bully had he been tough enough, so therefore bullying is natural. Is that a logical statement? canada goose deals
canada goose clearance sale He also observes that bullying is as “natural as ragweed and cancer.” Does that make a strong argument? Aren’t we trying to get rid of ragweed and cancer? canada goose clearance sale
Also, does the common equals okay argument work? Slavery, racism, Jim Crow, sexism, and anti Semitism have been and are common in certain societies. Does “majority rule” make for moral rule?
canadian goose jacket What Gottschall is saying is that bullying must be controlled through ritualized behavior. In hunter gatherer societies, the most extreme bullies were “assassinated by coalitions of fed up victims.” canadian goose jacket
canada goose clearance On the other hand, mainstream, run of the mill bullies thrive in adolescence and enjoy more dating success (35). canada goose clearance
Canada Goose Parka Two. What profound existential wound is Gottschall addressing in his book? Canada Goose Parka
Canada Goose Jackets He’s not talking about the need to win fights. He’s talking about not fighting back repeatedly when faced with an adversary or a hostile antagonist. Shrinking away shows a lack of heart and courage. And to shrink away over and over is to be full of shame and self loathing and to be loathed by others. To fight back, even in a losing cause, earns respect. But cowering away is to canada goose jacket outlet toronto lose Man Points. Canada Goose Jackets
Canada Goose sale Walter White of Breaking Bad has the body language of shame because he doesn’t fight back against his bully, Society, and canada goose parka uk gets kicked in the butt, poor, unable to take care of his family’s needs, working as a chemistry high school teacher and part time at a car wash where some of his students humiliate him (“You didn’t get the rims!”) Canada Goose sale.
Leave a Reply